Search Site
Menu

Presenting Your Case at Mediation


I recently learned that many plaintiff lawyers are deciding to forgo a presentation at the start of a mediation. You may know from past blogs that mediation is increasingly used as a form of alternative dispute resolution. Virtually every major case is mediated. Whether the mediation was worthwhile is the subject of another blog. Often mediation can be successful.

My approach has been to treat mediation as a very important part of the process. I was surprised to hear at a conference of a week or two ago that some lawyers are choosing not to present their case at the outset of the mediation. I disagree with that approach. I believe it is incumbent upon your lawyer to present the case very thoroughly and very coherently at a mediation. I don’t think there is an advantage to be had by simply waiving what you have a right to say and then proceed directly into the mediation. Why do I say this? Number one, you’re there to show your case to the the mediator despite his/her not having final control. In spite of the limitations in the power of a mediator (as opposed to the authority of an arbitrator) there is an advantage in impressing him/her with a well presented case. You’re there as well to impress the other side, particularly the insurance person who comes, presumably, with money to have the case resolved. I think that person needs to know that this case can be presented at a trial consistent with the manner you present it at mediation. There are a number of people you want to show that you believe in your case. Not only your own client who has a right to see his/her case presented effectively and strenuously, but the other side- insurer, lawyer, and mediator. This is their opportunity to hear from you, and your opportunity to synthesize all the evidence that has been marshalled to date. That evidence can come from documents, depositions, governmental investigations that bear directly or indirectly on your case, etc.

I think the client would be well-advised to discuss preparation with the lawyer before that day of reckoning comes, before that mediation. The mediation is the last day of reckoning before the ultimate reckoning, the trial. The argument against presenting something at mediation is why would you want to tip off the other side to what your strategy is? Well, my answer is your strategy should be pretty evident by the time of the mediation. If the case has been prepared and gone well, then your strong points won’t be a mystery to anyone. Indeed, the other side should know what the strong points of your case are. Lay down the gauntlet and let them know what arguments you will make at an opening, in the course of a trial, or in the closing.

Are you giving up too much? What about your closely guarded strategy? Obviously you don’t have to say 100% of your case but the basic thrust, the themes, can be revealed in my opinion. Surprise is typically something from an earlier day. Lawyers liked to engage in sandbagging. But the question is how much, if anything, are you giving up. Not much because the themes have already emerged; all you are doing as plaintiff’s lawyer is synthesizing. Now if in the course of discovery you’ve made the case very strongly and clearly, then I don’t think you’ll be surprising them when you present in a very strong and effective way, your case at a mediation.

Feinberg & Alban, P.C. fervently protects your rights
  • The Boston firm of Feinberg & Alban, P.C. specializes its practice in the area of personal injury.

    The attorneys serve the entire state of Massachusetts in addition to affiliating with lawyers in other states to handle cases outside of Massachusetts.

  • $7.7 Million Award for Feinberg & Alban Client in Personal Injury Trial

    Boston Attorneys Win Highest Injury Verdict in Massachusetts in 2011 & 2012.

Client Reviews
  • google
    5.0/5.0

    I suffered injuries and total loss if my car last year in a head on collision. Colleen Santora took my case and fought well on my behalf. She thoroughly answered all my questions and concerns, always responding in a quick and timely manner. She helpe...

    Read more

    Jessica Matt

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Choosing Feinberg & Alban was probably one of the best decisions I ever took. Robert Feinberg and Perry Feinberg are amazing in their professionalism as well as in compassion. Perry was the lead attorney for me. He was always responsive to any questi...

    Read more

    Raja Bhattacharyya

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    I would like to express my gratitude to Feinberg & Alban PC. They are great people and professionals. If you need an attorney these are your guys. Thank you so much! Tatiana

    Read more

    Tatiana Andreeva

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    It was unbelievable!! I got into a motorcycle accident didn’t remember a thing when I woke up I was in the hospital and very terrified I thought to myself I think I need a lawyer I started looking online and I came across this law firm let me tel...

    Read more

    Vin Loco

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Colleen Santora helped immensely in every step along the way of my fight against the insurance company regarding my property damage and injuries sustained. I'm grateful and would recommend Colleen to anyone! Thanks

    Read more

    DatDude Lex

See all reviews
Awards & Affiliations
Contact us

Quick Contact Form