Search Site
At the conclusion of a trial in the judge’s charge to the jury, the instruction will often be that the “defendant takes the plaintiff as he finds him”. That is an instruction that plaintiffs want. It is known as the “eggshell rule” meaning that if someone who is more susceptible to a serious injury or more susceptible to being injured in the first place, you, the defendant will be liable for that injury. (Exacerbation of an injury is a related issue but different enough to deserve a separate blog.)
I have always found the charge that “the defendant takes the plaintiff as he finds him” rather curious. It is not especially clear and cries out for clarification. Fortunately, it usually is clarified. I would prefer something along the lines of a plaintiff being entitled to be compensated in spite of having “special sensitivity”. At least that is clearer.
While on the subject of charges to a jury, I have always been amused by the following scenario. Issues pertaining to insurance are not admissible in a trial of negligence. (The exceptions are not relevant to this discussion.) Yet, in a premises liability case, invariably a judge will charge a jury along the lines that a landlord or owner of property is “not an insurer of the premises”. I have often wondered whether that causes jurors to think of insurance when the very word is verboten.
Feinberg & Alban, P.C. fervently protects your rights
Client Reviews
-
5.0/5.0Colleen and Robert were very responsive during a long process, always ready to answer our questions. They exhibited that much-needed combination of listening to us as clients and guiding us with their expertise, through all the delays and obstacles e...
-
5.0/5.0
Attorney Colleen Santora was amazing! I was hit by a car, completely overwhelmed and really just needed to focus on getting better. Retaining her, truly gave me peace of mind that all of the upcoming medical bills would be taken care of. I healed ...
-
5.0/5.0
While visiting boston, my husband was injured and required surgery, and the tribulations that followed. Living out of state, we had NO idea what to do, and we needed guidance. Collen and her team were and ARE a God sent. Colleen answered all of ...
-
5.0/5.0
I worked with Colleen Santora and had a great experience! I was very overwhelmed after my injury (MBTA at fault) and she made the process clear and easy. She always answered any questions I had and answered my emails within minutes every time. She al...
-
5.0/5.0
On vacation my mother had an accident in the Boston Airport that required surgery and prolonged physical therapy. It was a long, painful and extremely stressful process. My mother felt hopeless and her chronic pain was debilitating. My mother finally...
Awards & Affiliations
Contact us
