Search Site
Menu
What Does an Insurance Company/Defense Attorney Look for in a Personal Injury Case?

I am happy to invite a leading defense attorney to participate in this video blog. John Johnson has been defending civil cases for forty years and has been involved in some of the most serious personal injury cases in Massachusetts. That involvement has included the handling of not only trials but appellate cases. As you may be aware from my prior blogs, or from your own sources, appellate cases create most of the tort law or negligence law that we encounter in Massachusetts.

I thought it wise to ask John what he, as a defense attorney in serious accident cases, looks for in a plaintiff, or person suing. He mentions that his first person-to-person meeting with the person bringing the lawsuit is at a deposition. A deposition, unlike a trial, is not held in a courtroom, but is held in a lawyer’s office. The deposing attorney tries to elicit facts from the person suing. However, there is another dynamic that goes on: the assessment of the plaintiff is taking place. I have known about this aspect of depositions since I began working as a lawyer. I started working in a very busy defense law firm and I recall my boss who, if he were alive, would be in his eighties and always saying to me, “Now, I get to size her/him up.” Evidently, this is the common view of defense lawyers. As John Johnson says, he expects the person to be somewhat nervous and he attributes that to the process. One of the roles that he has as a defense lawyer is to determine if the nervousness is an understandable reaction to a formal process or if it’s due to something entirely different. Is the nervousness due to the witness’s concealing of information or to the desire to exaggerate? You should know that the deposing lawyer is filing a report with the insurance company and will report the facts as presented in the deposition but also will provide an assessment of the plaintiff. Will he or she make a good witness at trial? Is he or she likable? In my experience, the answers to those questions go a long way to determining if a case will be settled.

John Johnson also speaks of how he uses documents to assess the value of a case. He mentions that hospital records are relevant. Certainly, they tell us about the physical injury but, he, as defense attorney, is particularly interested in how the injured party has described the accident. It is generally felt that a person’s description is most reliable at a point that is closest to the time of the accident. That is just common sense. The individual has not had an opportunity to reflect upon the accident or to speak to a lawyer. Thus, there is an aura of authenticity to that description. To be sure, there are interesting evidentiary considerations on whether that description is admissible as evidence. There are some circumstances where it is admissible and others where it is not. Nevertheless, that description can go a long way to determining whether there is a personal injury settlement.

You will note that John continued to speak of exaggeration and/or overreaching on the part of the person bringing the injury action. He says, not surprisingly, that such exaggeration can hurt a case badly and discusses how such exaggeration is easy to detect. Even though John Johnson represents defendants and I represent plaintiffs, we are in full agreement on that point. Overreaching runs the risk of hurting the very valid injuries for which my clients seek compensation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Feinberg & Alban, P.C. fervently protects your rights
  • The Boston firm of Feinberg & Alban, P.C. specializes its practice in the area of personal injury.

    The attorneys serve the entire state of Massachusetts in addition to affiliating with lawyers in other states to handle cases outside of Massachusetts.

  • $7.7 Million Award for Feinberg & Alban Client in Personal Injury Trial

    Boston Attorneys Win Highest Injury Verdict in Massachusetts in 2011 & 2012.

Client Reviews
  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    Working with this firm was a great experience, they were very attentive to my case and needs ; the results of my case was better that I expected. Thanks to much to all the lawyers involved Sincerely S. Ponce

    Read more

    Client

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    I loved collaborating with my attorney. From day one it felt like teamwork: us against the world, david vs. goliath. There was an easy rapport, free flow of communication, yet she remained the consummate professional at all times. As a first-time pla...

    Read more

    Oyie Ndzie

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Excellent Firm! I cannot give enough praise to Colleen Santora who handled our case . Responsive, professional a true attorney who cares. The entire firm put it all together however Colleen brought it all to the table . Five stars does not seem to sa...

    Read more

    ed thomas

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    Atty Santora & staff were very responsive and handled my personal injury case with concern and professional care. I will recommend this firm for legal services.

    Read more

    Regina Benton

  • google
    5.0/5.0

    I had a wonderful experience working with Robert Feinberg and Colleen Santoro. I never once had doubts about how my case would be handled. I knew I was in great hands with both of them. I was always informed and felt confident in their ability to re...

    Read more

    Betsy Rose

See all reviews
Awards & Affiliations
Contact us

Quick Contact Form